The Problem:
Find \(I=\displaystyle\int_{0}^{2} (x^2+1)\,d\left \lfloor x\right \rfloor\)
My Doubt:
There seem two probable approaches to the question but both of them yield different results. Both seem to be mathematically correct and hence the confusion.
Approach 1:
We know that,
\(g(x). f'(x) + f(x). g'(x) = \large \frac{d\left(f(x). g(x)\right)}{dx}\)
Integrating the above expression we get:
\(\displaystyle\int_{a}^{b} g(x)\,df(x) + \displaystyle\int_{a}^{b} f(x)\,dg(x) = f(b).g(b)-f(a).g(a)\)
Using the above property to solve the integration we get the answer as \(\boxed{7}\)
Approach 2:
We can write
\(I=\displaystyle\int_{0}^{1} (x^2+1)\,d\left \lfloor x\right \rfloor +\displaystyle\int_{1}^{2}(x^2+1)\,d\left \lfloor x\right \rfloor\)
But \(\left \lfloor x\right \rfloor\) assumes constant values of \(\left \lfloor x\right \rfloor=0\) and \(\left \lfloor x\right \rfloor=1\) in the respective intervals. And hence in both cases \(d\left \lfloor x\right \rfloor=0\) and therefore \(I=0\)
I genuinely can't understand what's the correct method. I will really be grateful if someone can explain it to me.
Thank You!
Comments
Sort by:
Top NewestYour Approach 1 is fine.
In Approach 2, the floor function fails to be constant on the two subintervals; consider the two endpoints! The first integral takes the value of 1 due to the step at 1, and the second one takes a value of 5. With this correction, both approaches work and yield the same result. – Otto Bretscher · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply
First off, integration by parts doesn't work as the step function isn't differentiable.
Secondly, the integral is 2. I'll provide a proof of this later.
Btw, @Aditya Kumar The integral makes perfect sense and is defined. – Deeparaj Bhat · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply
It would be really nice of you to put the proof here if possible! But I would also like to know then what's wrong with the Approach 1&2 illustrated above? It's a bit baffling – Miraj Shah · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply
Wait, the integral is 7.
We shall use the definition of integration as given in this book, with \(\alpha(x)=\lfloor x \rfloor\) and \(f(x)=1+x^2\).
Consider a partition \(P\) of \([0,2]\) such that \(x_{r-1}\leq 1\leq x_{r}\) where strict inequality holds in atleast one of the two inequalities. Also, by the definition of a partition, we have \(x_{n-1}<2=x_n\). Then,
\[U(P, f, \alpha)=f(x_r)+f(x_n) \\ L(P, f, \alpha)=f(x_{r-1})+f(x_{n-1}) \\\implies \inf U(P, f, \alpha)=\sup L(P, f, \alpha)=f(1)+f(2) \\\implies \int_0^2 f \, d\alpha = 7\]
Note: I've only used the fact that \(f\) is monotonic.
Plus, in the book mentioned above, in the exercises, a more generalised version of IBP, valid for even discontinuos functions is given. You've made use of this version in approach 1 (luckily, the step function is monotonic).
If the integrals are calculated using the definition in approach 2, you get the right answer, 7.
@Miraj Shah @Aditya Kumar – Deeparaj Bhat · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply
Was this helpful? @Miraj Shah – Deeparaj Bhat · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply
Oh yes! Really helpful @Deeparaj Bhat ! Sorry for replying a bit late. Busy studying for the big one which is to be held on 22nd May! Actually the above problem was from a test paper it self! Had a doubt in the question, so thought of taking help from the brilliant Brilliant Community as I was pretty sure that I will be able to get at least some insight!
Thank you! – Miraj Shah · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply
You're writing any other exams? (Except JEE ADVANCED, which is on 22nd) – Deeparaj Bhat · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply
Actually yes. BITS and all! You have to give JEE this year? – Miraj Shah · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply
Yup. That, BITSAT and CMI in my case. – Deeparaj Bhat · 1 year, 4 months ago
Log in to reply