Waste less time on Facebook — follow Brilliant.

Conjecture about Continued Square Roots

Let \((s_n)_{n = 0}^{\infty}\) be a sequence of the form \(s_0 = \sqrt{a}, s_1 = \sqrt{a + \sqrt{a}}, s_2 = \sqrt{a + \sqrt{a + \sqrt{a}}}, ...\)

As \(n\) approaches infinity, the sequence approaches a "continued square root", a number of the following form:

\(x = \sqrt{a + \sqrt{a + \sqrt{a + ...}}}\)

I'll leave it as an exercise to show that if \(a > 0\), then this continued square root always converges, and the result is the positive root of the equation \(a = x^2 - x\).

Let's take \(a = 2\) as an example. By the formula I just mentioned, we have \(\sqrt{2+\sqrt{2+\sqrt{2+...}}} = 2\).

One question I asked myself is, how fast do these continued square roots converge to \(2\)?

To put it more precisely, let's consider the sequence \(2 - \sqrt{2}, 2 - \sqrt{2 + \sqrt{2}}, 2 - \sqrt{2 + \sqrt{2 + \sqrt{2}}}\), and so on. The decimal approximations for these numbers are 0.5858, 0.1522, 0.03843, 0.0096305, etc. Do you notice the pattern? The numbers seem to be getting about \(4\) times smaller each time.

Let's make this more rigorous. In the original sequence, we have \(s_{n+1} = \sqrt{2 + s_n}\). Therefore, \[\lim_{n \to \infty} \dfrac{2 - s_{n+1}}{2 - s_n} =\lim_{n \to \infty} \dfrac{2 - \sqrt{2 + s_n}}{2 - s_n} = \lim_{n \to \infty} \dfrac{(2 - \sqrt{2 + s_n})(2 + \sqrt{2 + s_n})}{(2 - s_n)(2 + \sqrt{2 + s_n})}\]\[ = \lim_{n \to \infty} \dfrac{4 - (2 + s_n)}{(2 - s_n)(2 + \sqrt{2 + s_n})} = \lim_{n \to \infty} \dfrac{1}{2 + \sqrt{2 + s_n}} = \dfrac{1}{4}\]

So, the differences between the continued square roots and their limit (2) do, in fact, approach a geometric sequence with \(\dfrac{1}{4}\) as the common ratio. Hence, \(s_n\) can be asymptotically approximated by a function \(s_n \approx 2 - \dfrac{b}{4^n}\).

Now, the million dollar question: What is this constant \(b\)?

In other words, what is \(\displaystyle\lim_{n\to\infty} 4^n(2 - s_n)\)?

I won't tell you the answer in case you want to solve it on your own. If you succeed, I'd love to see how you solved it so feel free to share it in the comments. If you'd like to see my solution, you can find it here.

Now let's generalize the previous result for the real number \(a\). Let's replace \(2\) with \(x^2 - x\), so that our sequence looks like this: \[s_n = \left\{\sqrt{x^2 - x}, \sqrt{(x^2 - x) + \sqrt{(x^2 - x)}}, \sqrt{(x^2 - x) + \sqrt{(x^2 - x)+\sqrt{x^2 - x}}} ...\right\}\] You can show (using a similar proof to mine above) that \[\lim_{n \to \infty} \dfrac{x - s_{n+1}}{x - s_n} = \dfrac{1}{2x}\]

Hence, the generalized sequence can be approximated by the function \(s_n \approx x - \dfrac{L_x}{(2x)^n}\) where \(L_x\) is the following limit: \[L_x = \lim_{n \to \infty} (2x)^n (x - s_n)\]

Now, I have a conjecture for you. I haven't been able to prove/disprove it yet; see if you can:

Let \(s_n\) be a sequence defined recursively by \(s_0 = \sqrt{x^2 - x}\) and \(s_{n+1} = \sqrt{(x^2 - x) + s_n}\) for \(n \in \mathbb{N}\), for some \(x > 1\). Let \(L_x = \lim_{n \to \infty} (2x)^n (x - s_n)\). Then,

\[ \lim_{x \to \infty} L_x = \dfrac{1}{2}\]

Note by Ariel Gershon
1 year, 1 month ago

No vote yet
1 vote


Sort by:

Top Newest

Just to confirm, is \(b=\dfrac{\pi^2}{16}\) ? Ishan Singh · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Ishan Singh Yes, very good! Ariel Gershon · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Ariel Gershon If we can solve the functional equation \(g(x)=a g^2\left(\dfrac{kx}{a}\right) - 1\) where \(a\) is a fixed constant and \(k\) is arbitarary, we are almost done solving the conjecture. Ishan Singh · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Ishan Singh I'm sorry, how would this help? Ariel Gershon · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Ariel Gershon Let \(f_{n}(y)=\underbrace{\sqrt{a+\sqrt{a+\ldots+\sqrt{a+y}}}}_{n \ \text{times}}\), substitute \(y=a\cdot g(x)\) to simplify \(f_{n}(y)\). We can then replace \(a\) by \(t^2-t\) and calculate \(L_{t}\) by letting \(n \to \infty\). Then we can find the conjectured limit by letting \(t \to \infty\). For example if we let \(a=2\), \(k=1\) we will get \(g(x)=2g^2(\frac{x}{2})-1\). One solution is \(g(x)= \cos (x)\). From this we can calculate \(b=\dfrac{\pi^2}{16}\). Ishan Singh · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Ishan Singh I'm missing quite a few steps in your logic.... What are \(g(x)\) and \(k\)? Ariel Gershon · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Ariel Gershon \(g(x)\) is an unknown function which satisfies \(g(x)=a g^2\left(\dfrac{kx}{a}\right) - 1\). If we substitute \(y=a\cdot g(x)\) in \(f_{n}(y)=\underbrace{\sqrt{a+\sqrt{a+\ldots+\sqrt{a+y}}}}_{n \ \text{times}}\), we have \(f_{n} (y) = a \cdot g\left(\dfrac{k^nx}{a^n}\right)\). And if we replace \(a\) by \(t^2-t\), we can then calculate \(L_{t}\) as a function of \(t\). This will simplify the conjectured limit \(L_{t}\). If my reasoning is missing any steps, you can ask and I'll try to fix it. Ishan Singh · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Ishan Singh OK, it makes more sense now as I was able to finish your argument. This is a very interesting approach! If you don't mind though, I'm going to simplify the equation for \(g\) to make it \(g(x) = a g^2\left(cx\right) - 1\) (since \(k\) is an arbitrary constant, let \(c = \dfrac{k}{a}\)).

There are two more stipulations for \(g\) and \(c\) which you didn't mention, but they are important. The proof by induction of this approach requires that the following be true:

(1) there must exist a real number \(z\) such that \(g(z) = \dfrac{\sqrt{a}}{a}\)

(2) \(g(c^n z) \ge 0\) for all \(n \in \mathbb{N}\)

Also, we can write \(f_n(a) = s_n\). Then by induction we can show that \(s_n = a * g(c^n z)\). If we replace \(a\) with \(t^2 - t\), then \(L_t\) will have the following formula: \[L_t = \lim_{n\to\infty} (2t)^n \left(t - (t^2 - t) g(c^n z)\right)\]

In the case of \(t = 2\), we can have \(c = \dfrac{1}{2}\) and \(g(x) = \cos(x)\), since, as you mentioned, \(\cos(x) = 2\cos^2\left(\dfrac{x}{2}\right) - 1\). We have \(z = \dfrac{\pi}{4}\) since \(\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{4}\right) = \dfrac{\sqrt{2}}{2}\). Then we get \[L_2 = \lim_{n\to\infty} 4^n \left(2 - 2\cos\left(\dfrac{\pi}{4*2^n}\right)\right)\] This limit does, in fact, evaluate to \(\dfrac{\pi^2}{16}\).

Interesting as this is, though, I think it won't be as easy to find \(g, c, z\) for \(t\) in general. Ariel Gershon · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

I want to point out that it only applies for \(a > 0\). (For \(a = 0\), it converges to the lower root of \(a = x^2-x\), namely \(x = 0\) instead of \(x = 1\).) Ivan Koswara · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply

@Ivan Koswara Fair point. I'll fix it Ariel Gershon · 1 year, 1 month ago

Log in to reply


Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...