Once my teacher gave a proof of 2=1 which is as follow:

{ 1 }^{ 2 }\quad =\quad 1\\ { 2 }^{ 2 }\quad =\quad 2\quad +\quad 2\\ { 3 }^{ 2 }\quad =\quad 3\quad +\quad 3\quad +\quad 3\\ .\\ .\\ .\\ .\\ .\\ { x }^{ 2 }\quad =\quad x\quad +\quad x\quad +\quad x\quad +\quad ........\quad upto\quad x\quad terms.\\ \\ Now\quad differentiating\quad both\quad sides\quad w.r.t\quad x,\\ 2x\quad =\quad 1\quad +\quad 1\quad +\quad 1\quad +\quad ........\quad upto\quad x\quad terms\\ ie,\quad 2x\quad =\quad x\\ \quad \quad \boxed { { 2\quad =\quad 1 } }

Now we were challenged to find the flaw in this proof ( Which we won )

Can you find the flaw in this proof ???

No vote yet

1 vote

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...

$</code> ... <code>$</code>...<code>."> Easy Math Editor

`*italics*`

or`_italics_`

italics`**bold**`

or`__bold__`

boldNote: you must add a full line of space before and after lists for them to show up correctlyparagraph 1

paragraph 2

`[example link](https://brilliant.org)`

`> This is a quote`

Remember to wrap math in $</span> ... <span>$ or $</span> ... <span>$ to ensure proper formatting.`2 \times 3`

`2^{34}`

`a_{i-1}`

`\frac{2}{3}`

`\sqrt{2}`

`\sum_{i=1}^3`

`\sin \theta`

`\boxed{123}`

## Comments

Sort by:

TopNewest$Since\quad x\quad can\quad take\quad only\quad positive\quad integral\quad values\quad \\ (as\quad { -1 }^{ th }\quad term,\quad { 0 }^{ th }\quad term,\quad { 0.5 }^{ th }\quad term\quad does\quad not\quad exists),\quad \\ the\quad function\quad { x }^{ 2 }\quad is\quad discontinuous\quad \\ and\quad thus\quad is\quad non\quad differentiable.$

Log in to reply

Thank you for posting this question.

You're trying to use the equality:

${x}^{2} = x + x + ... + x$

You are trying to differentiate two functions. Let's see what we know about them.

Let $f(x)={x}^{2}$. The domain for this function is clearly $R$. And yeah when we differentiate we get $f'(x)=2x$.

Let $g(x)= x + x + ... + x$ (for the equality to be true x repeats in the sum exactly x times), then since a number can't repeat itself $\sqrt { 2 }$ times the domain of this function is $N$.

Now you differentiate. Tell me how you can calculate:

$g'\left( { x }_{ 0 } \right) =\lim _{ x\rightarrow { x }_{ 0 } }{ \frac { g\left( x \right) -g\left( { x }_{ 0 } \right) }{ x-{ x }_{ 0 } } }$

But you can't approach ${ x } _ { 0 }$ on $N$. You can only differentiate on intervals or $R$.

More than this the differentiation gives you the slope of the tangent in ${ x } _ { 0 }$, but you can't have a slope to a function that's made of dots.

Even if we took $f$ defined on $N$ we still wouldn't have been able to differentiate it either.

So no, 2 isn't 1.

Log in to reply

Well the you only differentiated the x's,the number of x's should also be differentiated as it is also a variable

Log in to reply

Since this function is non differentiable , there is no question of differentiating the no. of x's

Log in to reply

Well,I dint even consider that lol

Log in to reply