×

# Nonconducting nonuniform non-nonsymmetric cylinder

A long, nonconducting, solid cylinder of radius 4.0 cm has a nonuniform volume charge destiny $$p$$ that is a function of radial distance $$r$$ from the cylinder axis: $$p=Ar^2$$. For $$A=2.5 \mu /m^5$$, what is the magnitude of the electric field at (a) r = 3.0 cm and (b) r = 5.0 cm?

So, clearly, I overdid it. See #2 for a legible version of solution to (a). For me, apparently, that was step one. So now the question is, WHAT ABOUT REPULSION? See below, the concentric circles on top right:

For every differential excerpt $$dr$$, the enclosed charge $$q_enc$$ generates an electric field perpendicular to the circumference. This field points both ways - outward and inward. Now, don't inward electric field lines of $$r+dr$$ cancel those of $$r$$ and form a certain $$E_{net_{r}}$$?

At first, I've tried to formulate an integral based on $$E_r - E_{r+dr}$$. You can imagine how that went ($$\int ...(r+dr)dr$$...). Then, I thought instead I should do $$E_{net}=E_r-E_{R-r}$$. It led to the circled big formula , derived after an hour of globbling - above.

Something was wrong. This equation is clearly not elegant. And when physics throws you an elegant problem, you must get an elegant answer. Then I realized something... do you know what it is? It made me mad. I'll leave it to you to figure out ;)

NOTE Spoilers ahead! If you don't know the answer to above, give it a thought!

So, what if we DID have to resort to such measures? What if there was no internal symmetric cancellation? How would we resolve that issue? Say, for example, we have a big rectangle - and its charge density obeys the same pattern as that cylinder. If we place the rectangle on origin with length parallel to y axis, let $$r$$ be $$x$$. What would be its electric field lines (assume it's infinitely long)? NOW my issue is real.