There are two players, player \(A\) with data set \(A\) and elements \(a_i\) and player \(B\) with data set \(B\) and elements \(b_i\). The arithmetic mean of each data set is 10 and 20, respectively.

A "game" is played in which each \(a_i\) is compared to its corresponding \(b_i\) with the same base. If the element from set \(A\) is less than its corresponding element from set \(B\), then player \(A\) is awarded 1 point and visa versa with player \(B\).

What is the probability that player \(B\) has more points than player \(A\)

You may manipulate the following or exclude them if they are not necessary. This is to either a) make this problem easier, or b) to make the problem possible.

A) The range of the data in both sets. (Make this \(0,\infty\) if possible)

B) The number of elements in each set. Notes:

\(~~~~~\) • The number of elements in sets \(A\) and \(B\) must be the same

\(~~~~~\) • The number of elements in set \(A\) determines the number of matches.

\(~~~~~\) • I don't think the number of elements matters, but it might

## Comments

Sort by:

TopNewestSo many possibilities here, depending on the particular distributions. A "game theory" question could go like this: Suppose player \(A\) must choose \(N\) (positive integral) scores with the only stipulation that they have a mean of \(\mu_{A}\), and player \(B\) must similarly choose \(N\) (positive integral) scores that have a mean of \(\mu_{B}.\) The scores are then ordered by each players and compared, in order, to those of the other player with the tally system you have indicated. What is the best strategy for the two players to achieve the maximum respective tally? Given that the two play optimally, what is the likely final tally as a function of \(N, \mu_{A}\) and \(\mu_{B}\)? I know that this isn't quite what you had in mind, but I thought I'd just throw it out there, anyway. :) – Brian Charlesworth · 1 year, 10 months ago

Log in to reply

– Trevor Arashiro · 1 year, 10 months ago

Yes, this is a much more feasible task. That turns this from more of a computer science problem into a combinatorics/NT problem.Log in to reply

Assuming that the number of elements in each set is the same and knowing the fact that the arithmetic mean from B is two times as the arithmetic mean from A, I think the probabilitiy is 1/2 – Catalina Villegas · 1 year, 6 months ago

Log in to reply