Note that you added an assumption that the triangle is right angled.

How would you deal with this for a general triangle?

The assumption of integer side-lenghts (and hence area) is reasonable. How would your interpretation change if the question was for any real side lengths?

For every set of angles \((A, B, C)\) that sum to \(180^{\circ}\), set \(R = \dfrac{\sin A + \sin B + \sin C}{\sin A \sin B \sin C}\). Then, the triangle with sides \(BC = 2R\sin A\), \(CA = 2R\sin B\), \(AB = 2R\sin C\) has area and perimeter equal to \(\dfrac{2(\sin A + \sin B + \sin C)^2}{\sin A \sin B \sin C}\). This gives us uncountably many triangles.

For a more direct approach, if a triangle has area \(A\) and perimeter \(P\), then if you scale the triangle by \( \frac{P}{A} \), it will have area \( A \left( \frac{P}{A} \right)^2 = \frac{P^2}{A} \) and perimeter \( P \frac{P}{A} = \frac{P^2} { A} \).

The \(R\) that you calculated reflects the above scaling.

I know that I added the assumption that the triangle is right-angled. This is because one of my friends wanted me to find all right-triangles with equal area and perimeter (both having an integer numerical value) a couple of weeks ago. So when I saw this question posted here, I immediately replied with the answer I remembered: the right triangles that have equal area and perimeter.

It turns out there are \(5\) triangles with integer side lengths and equal perimeter and area.

They are triangles with side lengths:

\((5, 12, 13)\)

\((6, 8, 10)\)

\((9,10,17)\)

\((7, 15, 20)\)

And \((6, 25, 29)\).

I started off by letting the side-lengths be \(a\), \(b\) and \(c\) and used Heron's formula for the area. And then it turned into a number theory problem.

A good solution to that can be found here and here.

I also learned that such triangles are called perfect triangles.

As for the side lengths being any real (don't you mean positive real?) numbers, Jimmy has shown that there are infinitely many such triangles.

In that case, let \(u\) be a unit distance, and let \(BC = au\), \(CA = bu\), \(AB = cu\). Find all triples \((a,b,c)\) of positive integers such that \([\Delta ABC] = (AB+BC+CA) \cdot u\).

## Comments

Sort by:

TopNewestIt is possible for right triangles with side lengths: \((5,12,13)\) and \((6,8,10)\).

Actually they are the only right triangles that satisfy this condition (perimeter equals area).

For its proof, see here.

Hope this helps!

EDIT: By the way, I assumed that you were talking about integer side-lengths and area.

Log in to reply

Note that you added an assumption that the triangle is right angled.

How would you deal with this for a general triangle?

The assumption of integer side-lenghts (and hence area) is reasonable. How would your interpretation change if the question was for any real side lengths?

Log in to reply

For every set of angles \((A, B, C)\) that sum to \(180^{\circ}\), set \(R = \dfrac{\sin A + \sin B + \sin C}{\sin A \sin B \sin C}\). Then, the triangle with sides \(BC = 2R\sin A\), \(CA = 2R\sin B\), \(AB = 2R\sin C\) has area and perimeter equal to \(\dfrac{2(\sin A + \sin B + \sin C)^2}{\sin A \sin B \sin C}\). This gives us uncountably many triangles.

Log in to reply

For a more direct approach, if a triangle has area \(A\) and perimeter \(P\), then if you scale the triangle by \( \frac{P}{A} \), it will have area \( A \left( \frac{P}{A} \right)^2 = \frac{P^2}{A} \) and perimeter \( P \frac{P}{A} = \frac{P^2} { A} \).

The \(R\) that you calculated reflects the above scaling.

Log in to reply

I know that I added the assumption that the triangle is right-angled. This is because one of my friends wanted me to find all right-triangles with equal area and perimeter (both having an integer numerical value) a couple of weeks ago. So when I saw this question posted here, I immediately replied with the answer I remembered: the right triangles that have equal area and perimeter.

It turns out there are \(5\) triangles with integer side lengths and equal perimeter and area.

They are triangles with side lengths:

\((5, 12, 13)\)

\((6, 8, 10)\)

\((9,10,17)\)

\((7, 15, 20)\)

And \((6, 25, 29)\).

I started off by letting the side-lengths be \(a\), \(b\) and \(c\) and used Heron's formula for the area. And then it turned into a number theory problem.

A good solution to that can be found here and here.

I also learned that such triangles are called perfect triangles.

As for the side lengths being any real (don't you mean positive real?) numbers, Jimmy has shown that there are infinitely many such triangles.

Log in to reply

Here's a problem though: the units are not the same for both sides. It's length squared for area while it's just length for the sum of the sides.

Log in to reply

In that case, let \(u\) be a unit distance, and let \(BC = au\), \(CA = bu\), \(AB = cu\). Find all triples \((a,b,c)\) of positive integers such that \([\Delta ABC] = (AB+BC+CA) \cdot u\).

Log in to reply