While thinking up interesting problems, I stumbled upon this interesting fact:

If \(x = 3n^2,\) for some positive integer \(n,\) then \(x^3 + 1\) can be expressed as the product of three distinct positive integers that form an arithmetic sequence.

For instance, when \(x = 12 = 3 \times 2^2,\) we have \(12^3 + 1 = 7 \times 13 \times 19.\) When \(x = 75 = 3 \times 5^2,\) we have \(75^3 + 1 = 61 \times 76 \times 91.\)

This statement is relatively easy to prove with some algebraic manipulation, but I'm having a lot of trouble with the converse. If \(x^3 + 1\) can be expressed as a product of three positive integers that form an arithmetic sequence, then must \(x = 3n^2\) for some positive integer \(n\)? If not, what are the counterexamples? I'd appreciate it if anyone here can provide some information about this!

No vote yet

1 vote

×

Problem Loading...

Note Loading...

Set Loading...

Easy Math Editor

`*italics*`

or`_italics_`

italics`**bold**`

or`__bold__`

boldNote: you must add a full line of space before and after lists for them to show up correctlyparagraph 1

paragraph 2

`[example link](https://brilliant.org)`

`> This is a quote`

Remember to wrap math in \( ... \) or \[ ... \] to ensure proper formatting.`2 \times 3`

`2^{34}`

`a_{i-1}`

`\frac{2}{3}`

`\sqrt{2}`

`\sum_{i=1}^3`

`\sin \theta`

`\boxed{123}`

## Comments

Sort by:

TopNewestIf \(x=3n^2\), then \(x^3+1=\left(3n^2\right)^3+1=\left(3n^2-3n+1\right)\left(3n^2+1\right)\left(3n^2+3n+1\right)\)

Log in to reply

Yeah, that’s how you prove the statement, but I’m asking about the converse.

Log in to reply

The converse is not true. Some counterexamples are:

\(719^3 + 1 = 189 \times 1040 \times 1891\)

\(719^3 + 1 = 70 \times 1647 \times 3224\)

\(1004^3 + 1 = 67 \times 2765 \times 5463\)

\(1655^3 + 1 = 621 \times 2072 \times 3523\)

\(2736^3 + 1 = 1142 \times 1939 \times 2736\)

and so on.

Log in to reply

Interesting. Is there an explicit formula or recursive definition to quantify all the counterexamples?

Log in to reply

Write \(x^3+1 = (n-a)n(n+a) = n^3-a^2n.\) Write \(x=n-b.\) Then we get the equation \[ 3bn^2 - (a^2+3b^2)n+(b^3-1)=0. \] Your case is \(b=1,\) which leads to \(n = \frac{a^2}3 + 1\) and \(x = \frac{a^2}3.\)

But there are plenty of other solutions, e.g. \(b=321,\) \(a=851,\) \(n=1040.\)

In general, this equation describes a cubic surface (or, more accurately, an affine open subset of a cubic surface) on which we are looking for integral points. This seems like it's pretty hard in general...

Log in to reply

Well, let's try a different value for \(x\). I will use the derivative of \(x\), which is \(dx/dn = 6n\). Now the value of \(x^3 + 1\) has a different value for \(x\).

Now let's put \(2\) in for \(n\) again. \(x\) still remains equal to \(12\), as \(12 = 6 * 2\). Once again we have \(12^3 + 1 = 7 * 13 * 19\).

However, putting \(5\) in for \(x\) upholds \(x = 30 = 6 * 5\). Now we have a whole different scenario. The equation is now \(30^3 + 1 = 27001\), which is only divisible by \(1\). Therefore, the arithmetic sequence \(a * b * c\) cannot output a value 27001.

I hope this helps. :)

Log in to reply

I'm not sure what you're doing here. From what I can tell, you defined the function \(x(n) = 3n^2,\) took its derivative, then claimed that if \(x'(n) = k,\) then \(x(n) = k\) as well. However, that last part isn't true; \(x'(n) = x(n)\) only for functions of the form \(Ce^n.\) Can you clarify for me?

Log in to reply

You're asking if the value \(x=3n^2\) for any positive integer \(n\) has to be in order for \(x^3 + 1\) to be a product of three integers. I'm showing that \(x^3 + 1\) cannot be a product of three integer, such that A) \(n\) is a positive integer, and B) \(x\) is any equation other than \(3n^2\). What I did was I assigned a different value for \(x\) then did the math to see if \(x^3 + 1\) can be a product of three integers. For some equations, this is not always the case.

This might not always be true, though. Try doing the same process, such that \(x=an^2\) and \(a\) is an integer other than 3.

Log in to reply

I have a problem \(x^3+1=6\) then \(x^3=5\) so x is not even an integer.Pls explain what do u mean by converse.

Log in to reply

The converse reverses the two parts of the conditional. So for the conditional "If \(x = 3n^2\) for some positive integer \(n\), then \(x^3 + 1\) can be expressed as the product of three distinct positive integers that form an arithmetic sequence," its converse would be "If \(x^3 + 1\) can be expressed as the product of three distinct positive integers that form an arithmetic sequence, then \(x = 3n^2\) for some positive integer \(n\)."

Log in to reply

that may not be always true by the above example that i gave since 6=1X2X3 (1,2,3 is an AP).But x is not necessarily an integer.

Log in to reply

What about when \(n=1\)? What arithmetic sequence of integers multiplies to give us 28?

Log in to reply

\(28 = 1 \times 4 \times 7\)

Log in to reply